I read an interesting article at the end of the year on ClickZ. It was about engaging the people on your email list who do not open or click on your company emails, your non-responders. I will focus here on how you can customize your emails for this group but for the full article see 4 Ways to Engage Email Non-Responders
Begin by segmenting your email list and create a separate list specifically for these non-responders. There is no need to make drastic changes to the people already engaging with your email communication unless your email format has not changed in a long time. You don’t want to risk your emails becoming stale and creating more non-responders. From there try these four tactics.
- Subject lines are a great way to mix things up. Alter your length, approach and cadence and see if that increases your open rate with this group.
- A good percentage of your list stopped opening your emails because you have been sending the same template with varying text that is never updated for six months or more. Freshen up your email and don’t forget to consider many email recipients open email on Smartphones nowadays.
- Place your offers at the top of the page. Whether you are a B2C or B2B company, your email recipient needs the WIIFM (what’s in it for me) up front. If they have to scroll you may lose them.
- Frequency is a debatable topic. Many feel sending emails less frequently is the best approach. This article actually recommended the opposite. Similar to in-person sales, staying in front of the prospect may be the better approach.
- Ask your non-responders for feedback or confirmation regarding receiving email from you. They gave you permission once and they haven’t opted out. Perhaps the key to turning non-responders into responders is to ask they what they would like or need.
If you try any of the above or have suggestions for motivating non-responders to become responsive, I would love to hear them.

